EXECUTION NOT WARRANTED
"Dadda, can you help me draw mummy on this piece of paper?" So says a two-year-old witness in The Murder of Rachel Nickell, a documentary that seems to want to dredge up something that happened almost 34 years ago. Um, let the victim's family be at peace will ya. And yeah, let's not now bother the dude that was falsely accused of Nickell's horrific passing via good old '92. Yeesh.
So OK, "Rachel Nickell" was directed by feature rookie Lucy Bowden, a woman who might have been swayed by Netflix's final, abrupt cutting. I mean why is the actual killer of Rachel revealed in the last five minutes on a whim? And why does little Alex Hanscombe now an adult (see first paragraph), suddenly show up in the last twenty minutes or so only to give very little insight into how his mum got stabbed 49 times a la broad daylight? And um, why was father Andre Hanscombe (Nickell's partner) so camcorder crazy that everything his fam did had to be so cataloged. Oh wait, it was the 90s. My bad.
Bowden, well she gives The Murder of Rachel Nickell a sterile, streamlined look, interspersed with what seems like prepped interviews, grainy archives, and slight reenactments. The editing is yardstick, the musical score by Andrew Skeet is mildly stirring, and "Rachel Nickell" has gained enough reverence to the point where it has also been made into an actual TV series (with real actors). "I saw it... Yeah I saw it all." Not so fast boss. Not so fast.
In closure, The Murder of Rachel Nickell fails however to be novel, or fresh, or anything other than humdrum existing. I mean it's like watching a combination of Dateline or 20/20 or even paranormal drama A Haunting, where instead of the camera readily peeking in we get something that's a little pat and/or smarmy. "Murder unincorporated."
Written by Jesse Burleson